Photo credit: Make Oakland Beautiful
A potential snag has emerged in
connection to the recently approved Oakland Army Base redevelopment deal.
A new community group called Make Oakland Beautiful has formed to
actively protest a portion of the deal that includes the construction of up to
five digital billboards near the base of the San Francisco-Oakland Bay
Bridge.
The group claims that in the army base agreement, the city all but hid the
portion of the deal that includes the billboard agreement, which gives most of
the future revenue from the boards to the billboard operator and army base
developer.
"This was so on the down low," said Karen Hester who co-founded the
group. "No one seemed to know anything about it, including most of the
media."
The agreement for the billboards would run for up to 66 years. Revenue
generated from rental use of the billboards would be divided up, with 60
percent going to the operator of the billboards, Foster Company. The city and
the developers of the army base would divide the remaining 40 percent, according
to a May 30 city staff report, with Oakland
receiving 75 percent of that amount.
Hester's group said that the large LED billboards also will be, "a visual
assault that will accost residents and visitors as they arrive over the new Bay Bridge
into Oakland and the East Bay."
"It's very disheartening that this has happened," she added. "I
support the development of the army base, but I don't think the city is being a
good steward of our natural resources."
Hester said the group is trying to secure a meeting with Assistant City
Administrator Fred Blackwell, who is overseeing the army base redevelopment
deal. Make Oakland Beautiful also is directing its anger not just at the city's
administration, but towards Councilmembers who voted for the deal.
The community group will hold its inaugural meeting on Thursday, Aug.
23. About 135 people have signed an online petition opposing the army base
billboards.
The Oakland Army Base deal was passed by City Council with great fanfare in late June. The $1 billion development agreement
allows developers Prologis and California Capital and Investment Group to lease
roughly 130 acres of the base land and create what they call a state-of-the-art
logistics center right next to the Port
of Oakland.
Oakland
developer Phil Tagami is leading this effort, which will include significant
infrastructure improvements, rail expansion and a deep water port terminal.
The deal still needs to clear a final hurdle. The council vote in June gave
the city administrator permission to complete final agreements with both the
port and developers.
The passage of the agreement by Council came after a 12 years of
negotiations - much of it centered on job development for local residents.
Government officials, along with developers and the business communities expect
the deal to creating thousands of jobs for Oakland.
Blackwell declined to sit down for an interview, but he said in an email that
city officials will meet with concerned residents about the billboard. He did
not specify a date for the meeting. As for the revenue agreement for the boards, he said, "The
billboard agreement is inline with local industry standards for revenue sharing
with landowners."
Blackwell indicated that the money from the billboards will be put to "important
use."
"While the actual revenue amount received by the city will vary depending
on the rental performance of the billboards, the revenue is estimated at
between $500,000 and $1 million per annum," he wrote. "While no
formal commitment of the revenue has been decided by City Council, there are
several programs related to the development project that might be funded. One
of them is the job training program to prepare Oakland residents for the new jobs that will
be created at the former army base."
Councilwoman Jane Brunner, who in the past has voted against erecting
billboards in the city, said her main focus this time around was negotiating
good jobs for Oakland.
"The only way to vote down the billboards was opposing the whole (army
base) deal," she said.